Staff Writer Jamal Malik-Lyf explores the question facing the long-lasting supremacy of WSL’s top four clubs.
Over the past few seasons, the Women’s Super League has been dominated by the same teams – Arsenal, Chelsea, Manchester City and Manchester United. But now, in the 2026/7 season, it looks like this traditional hegemony is under threat.
For the first time in a while, it looks like a new team will finally be able to finish in the top four, or even claim the title for themselves. The question that inevitably follows, then, is why are the traditional clubs struggling?
The first reason for this shift in power dynamic is simple; other teams are simply getting better. The standout performer so far this season is London City Lionesses, a relatively new club that was founded just 7 years ago and has no male equivalent.
After achieving promotion last season, they were able to consolidate their gains by finishing in a respectable sixth place, and this season they are looking like a formidable opponent by picking up a huge 16 points in only 7 games.
With standout performances from players like Van De Donk, as well as three-time Ballon d’Or winner and recent signing Alexia Putellas, London City are a force to be reckoned with as their quality is scarcely rivalled by the rest of the league.
When you pair their recently strengthened squad with the possession-based football orchestrated by Eder Maestre, it’s easy to see the squad finishing in the top four this season, and they may even be able to claim the title for the first time in their history.
The other and fairly obvious reason that the traditional hegemony is under threat is due to a string of poor performances by the established clubs. Whilst Chelsea and Manchester City have, predictably, gotten off to a strong start, Arsenal and Manchester United have struggled to gain the momentum that they had last season.
Regarding Arsenal, they have made their worst ever start to a Women’s Super League season, picking up two wins in 6 games. One issue is their lack of ruthlessness in front of goal, as undue hesitation is costing them huge points. The other problem can be seen in their tactical vulnerabilities, most prolifically in their failure to break down low blocks and poorly timed substitutions.
In Manchester United’s case, while they similarly struggle against low blocks, their issues are mostly stemming from a lack of identity within the club itself. With the appointment of new manager Eva Olid in the summer, the team have failed to adapt to a new system, resulting in confusion as they have caught between two differing approaches.
The question that remains, then, is whether the traditional powerhouses in the Women’s Super League will be able to reassert their dominance, or is it finally time for new clubs to take the helm? With rising clubs like London City looking unstoppable, and some of the big four fading away, it’s easy to see that the hegemony is under threat.





