Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Comment

We must uphold the right to dissent

Photo credit: Dulcie Lee

By Sebastiaan Debrouwere, KCLSU President

The other day I was at a debate where one of the speakers paraphrased a famous saying in Dante’s Inferno: “Those who do not abide by their principles will burn in the Seventh Circle of Hell.”

In all fairness, I grew up as an inquisitive – or, more appropriately, rebellious – child in a Catholic boarding school, and have been threatened with going to hell before. But still, now more than ever, this Dante’s stark warning resonates with me.

The scenes that took place last Wednesday, Thursday and Friday in Bloomsbury were appalling. We’ve seen footage of protesting students being kicked and punched. Tens of students were arrested, on a flimsy basis and often with draconian bail conditions. The scenes were reminiscent of those we usually see in televised reports of regimes cracking down on dissent and were, in my view, deplorable. While I don’t condone any violence directed at the police present, I most strongly condemn the police brutality we witnessed. On a university campus, this response is simply unacceptable.

For as long as we can remember, universities have been at the heart of debate and discussion. Our campuses have been bulwarks of free speech, of dissent, of opposition and of constructively seeking for new solutions to societal problems. Plurality is, and should be, embedded in the DNA of any educational institution.

Sometimes the dissent of students can be very uncontroversial. At KCLSU we’ve opposed the Immigration Bill, which will have a deleterious effect on the welfare of our international students, by meeting with our representatives. At other times, students will demonstrate. Just as freedom of speech is a right, freedom to peacefully dissent is a democratic right.

As a representative elected in a democratic system, I cannot remain silent when one of the most fundamental rights is eroded. I cannot idly stand by when a university takes out an injunction against protesting by its own students, meaning that from now on any protesters can be criminally prosecuted for being ‘in contempt of court’.

Whether students agree or disagree with a university, it is paramount that they should have a right to express their views. We should always be able to hold our universities to account. Put simply, students from across the political spectrum must unite on this issue. We demand that the integrity of our civil rights is upheld unconditionally.

In the next few weeks, I shall be seeking assurances from King’s that it will not crack down on peaceful protest activity by our students. Equally, I want to join the NUS in its call for an inquiry into the handling of last week’s protests. The principles of plurality are sacrosanct to me, and I will not burn in hell for not acting upon them.

 

I want to make it absolutely clear that I am writing this comment piece in a personal capacity. None of the opinions reflected should be taken as those of KCLSU, its Student Council or Trustee board.

About the author

Related

Comment

In response to the presence of Turning Point UK on Strand Campus, staff writer Zoé Courty argues the only effective way to counter the...

Hand writing mathematical formulas on a blackboard with chalk Hand writing mathematical formulas on a blackboard with chalk

Science & Innovation

Sports Editor Abyan Memon discusses the alleged breakthroughs OpenAI has made in the maths world. Two separate announcements by OpenAI revealed a frontier AI...

Science & Innovation

New Scientist Live 2026 (NSLive 2026) featured talks and exhibitions from scientists who specialise in a wide range of fields, from brain health to...

Mathematical formulas and abstract wireframe structures in grayscale Mathematical formulas and abstract wireframe structures in grayscale

Comment

From a military and security point of view, funding quantum and AI makes sense. From every other point of view, defunding curiosity driven (blue...

Pink spherical cells attached to a textured green structure against a black background Pink spherical cells attached to a textured green structure against a black background

Science & Innovation

Staff writer Luca Read discusses the initially promising but increasingly nerve-wracking research into CAR T cells for cancer research at King’s. Chimeric Antigen Receptor...

Comment

In response to the presence of Turning Point UK on Strand Campus, staff writer Zoé Courty argues the only effective way to counter the...

KCLSU & Societies

In an email sent to student leaders on 12 October, KCLSU said that neither it nor ratified student groups may enter into new “partnerships...

News

Several society leaders have complained of delays in accessing their allocated funds

News

This story covers topics that may be distressing to some, including sexual harassment, violence and assault. Students at King’s College London have told Roar...